As we enter the new fall season of television I find myself underwhelmed at the offerings. There’s not one show that makes me feel like, “Oooh, I’m definitely going to check that out.” I’m also noticing some disturbing trends. I was going to write one piece on what I’m liking/not liking about the direction of modern television. But in the interest of other folks like me with a short attention span, I decided to do a series of posts on the topic of the current landscape of television.
I’m a self proclaimed television freak! And once upon a time there were many shows I loved, but that’s not exactly the case anymore. The days of Alias/Felicity/ Frasier/Gilmore Girls and the fabulousness of Ugly Betty are over. (I know Ugly Betty was expensive to produce, but ABC made a huge mistake in cancelling this show too soon!) These types of shows were funny, smart, engaging and actually very deftly incorporated multicultural casting. (Yep, even Frasier finally got some brown folks on the show. For example remember when Martin Crane (the father) dated a black woman? And my twitter bud, Kim Coles appeared as the hilarious Dr. Mary. (“Okay? Okay!”)
But it would appear that at least in network television there is still a huge lack of brown folks in leading roles. Yeah NBC tried with Undercovers. But did they really try? It just didn’t work. Conceptually it was a great idea; a chocolate covered Hart to Hart, love it! But coming from J.J. Abrams, I was expecting a lot better-better casting (Gugu and Boris had zero chemistry) and frankly a better script. He got Alias right so I have no idea what happened.
Then NBC also tried with The Event. (Sigh) I couldn’t even figure out what the hell was going on. And by the time I kinda did, I didn’t care. And why was Blair Underwood Cuban? That detail seemed totally extraneous to me. Why couldn’t he have been plain ol’ black? Was him being Afro-Cuban central to the plot of his character? This was an example of diversity gone wrong, and made me wanna tell NBC to, “Keep it simple stupid.”
Okay, so we got past those disasters and now, as I predicted I think networks are taking those flops to justify not having any more black folks or other people of color in lead roles, giving us the old okeydoke. And now, seems networks have not only decided not to gamble on people of color in lead roles but to go back to creating programming that’s either completely obliterating people of color or casting them in obligatory token parts, like the upcoming Fox show, New Girl. This brings us to the latest trend in TV.
60’s Era Programming
Okay so we’ve done the vampires and other mystical creatures and now, there’s a fascination with the 60’s era. It began with Mad Men, which I don’t like. I tried watching it and thought, “Jeez would something happen already!” And for the fans, it’s not that I don’t get Mad Men, I don’t like it. Yeah it’s beautifully shot and the clothes are fab. So what? Who cares? Pretty much every character on that show is reprehensible or annoying in some way. I’m not invested and that is what draws me into a show. That’s what draws most people into the shows they love. We know that in Hollywood copycat is the name of the game. So in light of the fascination of Mad Men, we now have ABC’s Pan Am and NBC’s The Playboy Club.
I’m not on board with shows set in the 60’s. Hmmm… why? It wasn’t exactly the best of times for people of color. Even Julia Stiles, who starred in the NBC mini-series, The 60’s was aware of that when she reminded Carson Daly that the 60’s were very oppressive to black people when he said the 60’seemed like a fun era.
And if black actors are featured in these shows, they’re usually in socio/economically oppressed roles, something America seems to be comfortable with given the success of the movie, The Help. If a network is going to do a show in the 60’s I don’t see it as impossible to create one about a family of color who were in fact living the best lives possible. I think it would be interesting.
Okay Naturi Naughton was cast in The Playboy Club, so I guess that means something, but what? I’m not necessarily expecting her character to be treated the same way as the white bunnies, which would be an authentic portrayal. And I would appreciate that, if in fact the show will be making a statement about the times. To bring up race in the show just to be controversial will be cheap.
I wasn’t even sure that there were in fact black playboy bunnies, but an
article in the Grio about the first black woman to “grace” the cover of
Playboy proves there were. Okay, great. I would give NBC, a network that’s been overtly struggling with diversity ever since
The Cosby Show went off the air, credit for incorporating an African American character on a show set in the 60’s. But then I saw Naughton’s
bio for
The Playboy Club on the NBC site:
“Naturi Naughton stars as Brenda, the beautiful African American Playboy Bunny with big aspirations, in NBC's provocative drama "The Playboy Club."
First of all the punctuation is wrong. (The period should be outside the quotes of the show.) And secondly, um, NBC, do we need you to tell us Naughton is black? If her race is a central aspect of her character’s experience on the show, then expound upon that, otherwise I think it can obviously be omitted. The bios for the show don’t identify other actors as white, and doesn’t need to.
And ABC’s Pan Am has no characters of color-none that I could find anyway. In 2011 are we still living in a world where it’s okay to have only white people cast in a show? I’m not okay with it. And I’m not okay with 60’s era shows that serve as an excuse to obliterate people of color, exploit our socio/economic position in that time for entertainment, or treat us as obligatory scenery without allowing full explorations/expositions of ourselves as human beings. (And it's funny that when I went to ABC's site, there's an ad for President Obama's 2012 campaign! Conflicting messages?)
So I may check out Pan Am and The Playboy Club out of curiosity. And I’ll be looking to see how Naughton’s character is portrayed and treated. But overall I’m not a fan of shows set in times where it was legal to discriminate against people of color that leave us completely out of the picture or just include us for decoration.
What do you think about this 60’s era trend?
photos courtesy of ABC and NBC